Copycat Shake Shack Cheese Sauce
Prep: 10 mins Cook: 20 mins Yield: ~3 cups See recipe card for live cost
Anne Rose
If you want to put something actually good on your burgers — not just ketchup — this copycat Shake Shack cheese sauce is the move. It's that warm, melty, tangy cheese sauce Shake Shack drizzles over their burgers and fries, and it tastes exactly like the real thing for a fraction of the cost. Best part: this is basically the official recipe (Shake Shack's own culinary director shared it), just made easy for your kitchen.
It's the kind of thing that turns a normal cookout into "wait, who made this?!" Pour it over fries, spoon it onto a smashburger, or keep a bottle in the fridge to fancy up whatever you're eating. Cheap to make, ridiculously good, guaranteed to impress.
This site contains affiliate links — view the disclosure for more information.
All dishes are made and tested by Anne Rose. Click here to learn more.
“Honestly, adding this to burgers or fries makes the most amazing meal ever — perfect for when you want to pig out or impress your friends. 😄” — Anne
The Real Shake Shack Cheese Sauce, Made at Home
The secret is the infused cream: you gently cook onion, jalapeño, peppercorns, and salt in oil, add white wine and heavy cream to steep up all that flavor, then strain it smooth and melt in American and cheddar. That aromatic base is what makes it taste like Shake Shack instead of plain nacho cheese. It's a one-pot sauce that comes together in about 30 minutes.
- Prep Time 10 mins
- Cook Time 20 mins
- Yield ~3 cups
- Cost / Serving See card
Share This Recipe
Good food is even better when it's shared.
My Kitchen Tools
These are the tools I use and love to make this recipe (and life in the kitchen!) easier. You don't need any fancy equipment—just a few favorites that make a big difference!
-
Recommended
Squeeze Bottles
Bottle it up and drizzle over fries and burgers just like the shop.
View on Amazon → -
Optional
Stainless Steel Mixing Bowls
Handy for prepping and holding the strained cream.
View on Amazon → -
Optional
Stainless Steel Whisks
For stirring the cheese in smooth.
View on Amazon →
Sauces & Dips
Recipe Title
Cost: $0.00 recipe / $0.00 serving
Infuse, melt, and serve — photos of the finished sauce are above.
Infuse, melt, and serve — photos of the finished sauce are above.
Ingredients
Instructions
Notes
Email Me This Recipe!
Get this recipe sent straight to your inbox, plus get new recipes from us every week!
Nutrition Information
Serving:
Calories:
Serving Suggestions
Bottle it up and keep it in the fridge next to your other sauces. It's unreal on cheese fries, smashburgers, hot dogs, nachos, or as a dip for pretzels — basically anything you'd want to make melty and cheesy. It plays nice next to your other homemade sauces, too — Wingstop Ranch, Copycat Chick-fil-A Sauce, and Copycat Raising Cane's Sauce.
Storing & Reheating
Keep it refrigerated in a sealed jar or bottle for up to 4–5 days. It thickens when cold — reheat gently in the microwave (in 20-second bursts, stirring) or on low on the stove, adding a splash of cream or milk to loosen it back to that pourable, drizzly texture.
Don't freeze it — the cream and cheese will separate and you won't get that silky Shake Shack drizzle back.
Substitution Tips and Recommendations from Our Audience
Straining is the key step — use a fine-mesh strainer to get that silky texture. No strainer? A slotted spoon or a scooper with holes will get most of the solids out and still works great.
-
No fine-mesh strainer: a slotted spoon or a scooper with holes will get most of the solids out and still works great.
-
Cheese fries texture: thin the finished sauce with a splash of milk or cream if you want that extra-drizzly Shake Shack cheese-fries pour.
Frequently Asked Q's
What cheese Shake Shack uses, how to make it, gluten, calories, and what to put it on.
Q: What cheese does Shake Shack use?
American and cheddar, melted into an infused cream. That's the combo that gives you the melty, tangy Shake Shack cheese sauce instead of plain nacho cheese — and it's the same mix their culinary director shared.
Q: How do you make copycat Shake Shack cheese sauce?
Cook onion, jalapeño, peppercorns, and salt in oil, add white wine and heavy cream to infuse, strain out the solids, then melt in American and cheddar. About 30 minutes, one pot, and you've got the official recipe made easy.
Q: Is Shake Shack cheese sauce gluten free?
This homemade version is — it's cheese, cream, aromatics, oil, wine, and vinegar. Double-check your cheese labels if you're cooking for someone with celiac, since some processed American cheese can include extras.
Q: How many calories are in Shake Shack cheese fries?
The sauce itself is about 280 calories per ¼ cup serving. Restaurant cheese fries will be higher once you add the fries — this recipe is just the sauce, so you can pour as much or as little as you want.
Q: What do you put Shake Shack cheese sauce on?
Cheese fries, smashburgers, hot dogs, nachos, pretzels — basically anything you'd want to make melty and cheesy. Bottle it and keep it next to your other sauces.
Share This Recipe
Good food is even better when it's shared.